Why “Tough Love” Fails

I was once pushed into the deep end of a pool before I had actually learned how to swim. Obviously, I sank after panicking and splashing around. Thankfully I was pulled out! But after I was “toughened up” with that sink or swim lesson, I never swam again.

To this day, I still can’t get in a pool. I’m afraid I might end up upside down, no lifeguard watching, no one to pull me out. That moment didn’t teach me strength—it taught me fear. The water stopped being a space of learning and became a place of quiet dread.

And I see the same thing happen in nursing.

When new nurses are thrown into patient care with minimal guidance or support, they don’t always “rise to the occasion.” Some freeze. Some question their worth. Some leave the profession entirely.

Tough love doesn’t always create strong nurses. Sometimes it just creates survivors—exhausted, burnt out, and doubting their place.

Let’s dive in!

The Myth of Tough Love in Nursing

You’ve probably heard it on the floor:

“We had to toughen up, so you should too.”
“Nursing isn’t for everyone—let’s see if you can handle it.”
“We’re not here to hold hands. Just figure it out.”

It’s framed as tough love. But here’s the hard truth: tough love isn’t always love. Sometimes it’s a defense mechanism. Sometimes it’s unprocessed trauma. Sometimes it’s just the culture we inherited, unexamined.

And instead of building resilience, this approach often breeds silence and shame. Instead of cultivating strong, compassionate clinicians, it weeds out those who might have thrived—with the right kind of support.

Before We Move On...

If you’re thinking, “That’s just how it is,” ask yourself:

How many times have you heard, “Figure it out yourself”?
How often did you feel too afraid to speak up?
What would’ve changed if someone had simply said, “I’ve got you”?

These aren’t just phrases—they’re patterns. And they shape whether someone grows… or shuts down.

Why It Doesn’t Work

Emotional cost:
Tough love often creates internal chaos—stress, imposter syndrome, self-doubt. Nurses start questioning not just their skills, but their belonging.

Professional cost:
When nurses are afraid to ask questions, patient safety suffers. When fear replaces curiosity, we miss chances to learn, grow, and improve care.

A small story:
I remember a new nurse on the unit who hesitated during a code. She wasn’t unsure of the protocol—she was afraid to speak up. She’d been told one too many times to “figure it out.” That hesitation stuck with her longer than the code did.

Tough love didn’t make her quicker next time—it made her quieter.

Contrast:
Where tough love silences, mentorship speaks. Where shame isolates, guidance connects.

What New Nurses Actually Need

Support is not coddling. It’s preparation.

Supportive communication: Correction can be clear without being cruel.
Safe learning spaces: New nurses should feel safe to say, “I don’t know.”
Constructive feedback: Feedback should build confidence, not bury it.

“Support builds confidence. Intimidation builds fear.”

Changing the Culture

Culture doesn’t change overnight—but it does change one interaction at a time.

Senior nurses: Be mindful of the legacy you’re passing down. Trauma isn’t tradition.
Leaders: Model what mentorship looks like. Make it visible.
New nurses: Advocate for yourself. Ask for help. Say the quiet things out loud.
👉 What’s one thing you wish senior nurses understood about being new?

Love That Builds, Not Breaks

Tough love might look like strength—but it often teaches survival, not growth.

Real strength? That’s mentorship. Compassion. Presence.
It’s remembering that every confident nurse was once a shaky one—and they didn’t get there alone.

👉 Share a moment when someone supported you instead of pushing you down—or tell us how you’ll be that support for someone else.

💬 Now I’d love to hear from you:
👉 What’s one thing you wish senior nurses understood about being new?

👉 Share a moment when someone supported you instead of pushing you down—or tell us how you’ll be that support for someone else.

Share it in the comments—you never know who your words might help.

💬 Join the Conversation:

Share your stories in the comments or reach out—I’d love to hear from you.

What’s one thing you wish senior nurses understood about being new?
Share a moment when someone supported you instead of pushing you down—or tell us how you’ll be that support for someone else.
Any tips or stories you'd like to share with your fellow new nurses?

💙If you are not on our email list, click the contact link here.

💙Don’t forget to follow me on my Instagram account @nclex_one_on_one_tutoring and share it with your colleagues!

Want Mentorship?

If you’re a new nurse (or an experienced one) who wants help building communication skills, I’m here to support you.

Let’s imagine a nursing culture where we handle conflict with courage, professionalism, and care—not fear or silence.

Let’s build that together.

Why “Tough Love” Fails in Nursing (And What Actually Builds Resilience)